Q&A: Katherine Reay

November 4, 2013

Good morning, peeps! Today, we have a first here on Dreaming Under the Same Moon… and I am thrilled about today’s fun. Not only was I given an opportunity to review Dear Mr. Knightly but I have also been able to chat with its author Katherine Reay (who is a lovely lady!) online and as a result of that, I asked if she’d be willing to do a Q&A and she said, yes! Hooray!

Without further ado, please welcome Katherine Reay!

Q: Hello, Katherine! First off, thank you so much for agreeing
to stop by Dreaming Under the Same Moon to celebrate your debut novel – I’m
delighted to welcome you! Could you please share a bit about yourself and your
debut novel? 

Katherine Reay: First of all, thank you so much for inviting me. I’m
completely delighted and honored to be here… What to share? Hmmm… I run lots
of half marathons and have endured one full marathon and have another on the
books for next spring. Like a character in Dear
Mr. Knightley,
I earned my black belt in tae kwon do and I do believe it’s
my favorite accessory. I have three fantastic kids who keep me on my toes and a
most spectacular husband who thinks everything I do is brilliant. (Okay, that last
bit made me chuckle too.:)) I think of myself as a Midwesterner, but I’ve lived
all over the country from Atlanta to Seattle, and even called both England and
Ireland home for several years. 

Now, I’ll move on to the book… I wrote Dear Mr. Knightley while recovering from an injury – a time when
many of the above activities were taken out of my life. I am pleased to say
they’re all back in, but to differing degrees. Now I write. Lots. And I love
it! I love exploring our pasts and finding the ways they define our futures. You
see it in history, literature and our own lives. Dear Mr. Knightley let me bring this passion to the page with Sam
and all the wonderful people, literary and real, surrounding her. 

Q: Your debut novel, Dear
Mr. Knightley
was, obviously inspired by Jane Austen – aspects of her
influence are most noticeable when readers begin to realize Sam feels safest
when she’s lost in her books and is with those she considers “friends,” but
what was the writing process like to use Austen inspiration and interpret a part
of Austen into a contemporary? And more specifically how did the idea of
telling the story entirely through letters come about…

KR: The idea originally came from Jean Webster’s Daddy Long Legs. It’s an epistolary
novel as well – and keeping Dear Mr.
in this format was a tough, hard fought choice. A few critiques
strongly suggested I change that. But it was right for the story and I’m so
grateful Thomas Nelson/ HarperCollins felt the same. Letters are unique – the
reader almost feels like it presents a first person view, but it does not.
There’s a delicious layer the reader can see that the letter writer (Sam, in
this case) can’t – there is what she is willing to tell Mr. Knightley, what she
tries to withhold and how she interprets events – any or all of which can look
to different to us than to her. I loved the format and what I could reveal
within it. As for bringing Austen into it, that was so natural and seamless,
partly because our favorite movies and books play such an important role in our
lives. It was also tremendous fun as I wasn’t putting Austen into “today” so
much as I was letting Sam step back into the safety of Austen.  Some days I’d like to live within that fiction
as well. 

Q: Taking away the inspiration that you drew from Jane Austen,
what did you use as emotional inspiration for Sam’s character? She was a girl
that many of us could relate to – if not in her home life, then her difficulty
“fitting in” or keeping relationships intact. 

KR: I’m thrilled you felt that way. I purposely made Sam’s life
bigger, tougher, and more challenging than many of us face so that we could
more easily sneak into her emotional world and realize her struggles are
universal. I think we all strive to define ourselves, face insecurity and fear,
seek a place to stand and belong, and search for a family to love.  So I guess I’d say a lot of that came from my
own life and taking my emotions larger. Sam and I share no common history, but
– as you say – all the feelings translate. 

Q: Who was your favorite character to write and who the most

KR: I love them all – and that is not a dodge to the question. I
loved plotting Josh’s subtle selfishness, Ashley’s debutant aura, and Professor
Muir’s feistiness… But Kyle was one of my favorites. I love everything about him
and I’m so glad he found Coach Ridley, another favorite. 

Mrs. Muir was the most challenging. She is goodness. She is
patience and serenity. And I wanted to bring all that to the page without
making her “milk toast,” because she has an amazing strength that shouldn’t be
diminished. However, I possess more of Professor Muir’s feistiness or Sam’s
determination or even young Isabella’s naiveté 
– Mrs. Muir is my aspiration, but not my reality. 

Q: Just for fun, who would you cast in the roles of Sam and any
other main protagonists from Dear Mr.

KR: So tough…

Can I have Lily Collins for Sam? She is about the right age
and has the eyebrows. Eyebrows are a defining feature for Sam and Miss Collins
has gorgeous ones. 

Jaden Smith is about to age-out of Kyle so let’s start
filming soon! 

And Alex… James Marsden. Please!
Q: Having read your novel, Dear
Mr. Knightley
and thoroughly enjoyed everything about it, I have to say
that I’m tickled to know there is a second book from you coming, is there
anything you can share about it? 

KR: I’m so excited about Lizzy
and Jane
. I loved writing it and I adore the characters within it. And it’s
got all the big guns: sisters, conflict, food, Jane Austen, Hemingway (threw
you there, didn’t I?), love, and breast cancer. I know that last one is a bummer,
but it’s a reality that so many of us experience either personally or walking
the journey with family and friends. Basically Lizzy and Jane is the story of a young woman, Lizzy, who has
excised love from her life and, as she helps her sister through chemotherapy,
she starts to put it back in – in all its wonderful and varied forms. I love
these sisters and the men in their lives…

Katherine, again, thank you SO much for agreeing to this! I am impressed by that black belt, your inspiration for DMK, what you say about Sam’s emotional psyche and love who you’d cast in the leading roles (excellent choices). Plus, oh my! Your followup novel sounds like an emotional roller-coaster – one I cannot wait to uncover.

Visit Katherine on-line:
Facebook ▪ Twitter ▪ Website

Learn more about Katherine’s debut in its feature review post plus there’s a chance to win a copy!


  • Heidi

    November 4, 2013 at 5:50 pm

    Fun interview! Looking forward to reading the book!

    1. Rissi

      November 4, 2013 at 8:55 pm

      I was just thrilled Katherine was willing to do this, Heidi. :)

      Hope you enjoy the novel – it's a keeper and then some.

  • Lilly Jackson

    November 4, 2013 at 6:32 pm

    ME TOO. I want to read this book….SOON.

    1. Rissi

      November 4, 2013 at 8:54 pm

      It is a jewel of a novel, Lilly – definitely one of my most favorites of 2013! :)

  • Hannah Barta

    November 4, 2013 at 7:37 pm

    Aw! I can't wait to read Dear Mr. Knightley and her Lizzy and Jane sounds absolutely adorable.

    1. Rissi

      November 4, 2013 at 8:51 pm

      Ditto! Agree completely, Hannah; Lizzy and Jane does sound wonderful – definitely one that will tug at our heartstrings.

      Hope you love DMK. It's a jewel.

  • Jillian

    November 4, 2013 at 8:26 pm

    This Q&A was so fun to read, especially since I just finished reading Dear Mr. Knightley :) I actually pictured Sam just like Lily Collins! Looking forward to reading Lizzy and Jane.

    Rissi, do you know how I can italicize in blog comments? Sorry if it's a silly question. Thanks!

    1. Rissi

      November 4, 2013 at 8:43 pm

      Wasn't this a blast!? I am so honored that Katherine agreed to this. :)

      Hooray! You finished this one, Jillian!? That is just… AWESOME! I'm so pleased you were able to read it. Same here; I love the idea of Lily playing Sam. She's a unique actress and since Sam is also a unique, lovable, lovely character, that'd be appropriate.

      As am I! Cannot wait for the release of Lizzy and Jane! Sounds so emotionally heart-tugging.

      Italicizing comments, not a silly question at all! How to explain it… you know I'll send you a quick email with pics. because I don't want the word to italicize when trying to show you. :)

  • Raquel

    November 5, 2013 at 12:46 am

    Lily Collins and James Marsden?!?! Ah. I'm dead. This book is going to be incredible.

    1. Rissi

      November 5, 2013 at 8:11 pm

      Tell me about it, Raquel. :)

  • Carrie Turansky

    November 5, 2013 at 1:48 am

    This book sounds delightful! It's not on my wish list!

  • Carrie Turansky

    November 5, 2013 at 2:06 am

    I forgot to say I LOVED Daddy Longlegs and read it several times when I was a girl. It's so fun to see you've chosen that same style. : )

    1. Rissi

      November 5, 2013 at 8:14 pm

      It sure is delightful, Carrie! Hope you enjoy the book. :)

  • Amy Putney

    November 5, 2013 at 4:28 am

    Fun interview! This book sounds like such a great read! I hope to get a chance to read it soon!

    1. Rissi

      November 5, 2013 at 8:15 pm

      Hope you can read it soon also, Amy. It's a keeper and then some. :)

  • Beth

    November 5, 2013 at 2:13 pm

    You had me at "epistolary" – I think my favorite book in this format so far is The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society. So eager to get to this one!


    1. Rissi

      November 5, 2013 at 8:15 pm

      Yay! Glad this Q&A made you curious, Beth. Happy reading. :)

  • Chasity S.

    November 5, 2013 at 9:17 pm

    How fun to learn more about her!

    1. Rissi

      November 6, 2013 at 5:24 pm

      It was indeed; I loved reading through Katherine's answers. :)

  • Miss C

    November 6, 2013 at 4:12 am


    1. Rissi

      November 6, 2013 at 5:24 pm


  • Anonymous

    November 6, 2013 at 5:43 pm

    Rissi, I absolutely LOVED Dear Mr. Knightley!!!! This interview was so much fun to read. Also, I think Katherine's choices of celebrities are perfect. Happy Reading!

    1. Rissi

      November 6, 2013 at 5:56 pm

      Hooray! I am SO glad you loved this novel – me, too! Cannot wait to see your review. I loved reading Katherine's answers also – she offers some really interesting insights for us.

      …and I agree, those casting choices ROCK!

      Thanks for dropping by. :)

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

(Enter your URL then click here to include a link to one of your blog posts.)

Prev Post Next Post

Get the latest posts delivered to your mailbox:

%d bloggers like this: