Janette Oke is one of the premiere authors not to mention instrumental to bringing inspirational fiction into more recognition. In case you missed it, the Hallmark Channel has produced her Canadian West series into this scripted, nice-week, hour-long series and so far, any fan should know, if you’re missing this, then you’re missing a fabulous production. Here are some thoughts on the next episode, “A Telling Silence.”

When Calls the Heart, Season One Episode 3

Hardships or no, Elizabeth (Erin Krakow) has proved she has some mettle no matter her city upbringing. With the women of Coal Valley finally understanding that Elizabeth is more than a pretty face, she sets about teaching their children and is troubled by the lack of communication from young Rosaleen. Not only does she refuse to speak, the girl won’t color or express any emotion. When she goes missing, the town learns new things about its members.

‘WHEN CALLS THE HEART,’ SEASON ONE EPISODE 3 (2014). Reflecting on the third episode of Hallmark's popular series. Text © Rissi JC

Meanwhile, life for the handsome Mountie posted in Coal Valley, Jack Thornton (Daniel Lissing) is beginning to get difficult. With his job come new suspicions when it appears the church burning down was the result of arson.

RELATED NETFLIX REVIEW | ‘Enola Holmes’: The Fierce Holmes Outwits the Smart One

Out of the episodes so far, this is my least favorite though not because it does anything “wrong,” rather it lacks importance as a separate story. As a “bigger” piece of the puzzle in the 10-episdoe order, it fit very nicely. Some of these episodes I suspect won’t work as attractively as individual episodes. Last time we chatted about this series, I didn’t mention the scenery, and really it’s a shame since the camera does scan some gorgeous countryside.

Of course, the moments between Lissing and Krakow continue with fabulous chemistry – swoon. If the next episode synopsis is any indication, we’re finally going to focus in on that. Of course the fact that the hero is in uniform doesn’t hinder anything; something about a uniform does seem to appeal to us, girls, right!? And here ends my fangirl-ing. Uh-huh, moving on.

What does start to build in this story is a mystery possibly surrounding the women left a widow as a result of the mining accident and if it plays out a bit, I think it could make for a great plot line. There’s nothing like hints of mystery to keep even the best guesser curious.

This ends my thoughts on When Calls the Heart, season one episode 3.

Photos: Hallmark Channel / Crown Media Press

About Rissi JC

amateur graphic designer. confirmed bookaholic. bubbl’r enthusiast. critical thinker. miswesterner. social media coordinator. writer.


  1. FANGIRLING over this show!! Perfect cast, spots of mystery, and very soon a swoon worthy romance. (hopefully) And I'm hoping for at least 1 kiss between Jack & Elizabeth before the season ends. I am very much looking forward to purchasing Season 1 on DVD!!

    1. Same here, Alyssa. I think the show is going to work best as a "bigger picture" scenario rather than individual scripted stories but still… I'm very much invested in the show and am glad Hallmark is producing it.

      *Swoon* I love Jack and Elizabeth together – they're so cute and the moments between them? Aww… I love that they're subtle moments rather than "sultry." And I suspect a S1 kiss will happen. :)

      Yay for a DVD – here's hoping it goes up for pre-order soon.

    1. I know what you mean, Melissa – and I like the way you think! Just wait and watch it all together. There's NO wait that way and hooray, that's always a plus. :)

  2. Rissi, I have to agree with you that I found this to be one of the least interesting episodes. Perhaps the subject matter of someone being so silent is a difficult one to convey in an interesting way. That is, if she's not talking, we're missing some of the dialogue. And I think the episode was also hurt by the absence of one of the 3 main leads, Abigail. Further, I found the scene of Elizabeth carrying Rosaleen home was a bit over-the-top in its corniness.

    But, as with all epsiodes of this show, there were some great highlights. The scene of Cat Montgomery leading Sunday services out in the woods was great on many levels.

    It was in this episode that I first picked up on a rather amusing pattern of Jack and Elizabeth that was repeatedly shown throughout the season. It occurred here when Jack approached Elizabeth at the end of class when a Latin saying was on the blackboard. After demonstrating his knowledge of the word "bella," clearly a compliment to Elizabeth, he immediately followed by joking about a boy who remained sleeping at his table.

    Jack and Elizabeth often follow a tiny step toward admitting romantic feelings by either suddenly being overly formal ("Ma'am", "Constable") or retreating into adolescent teasing. I think the teasing works because it is balanced by their mature and focused attitudes toward their respective careers. (By the way, I think it was in episode 2 where they had a great scene in which they showed Elizabeth working late at night dowstairs in the saloon, while Jack was upstairs in bed, reading a book about liability law by candlelight.) Mature at work? Deifnitely. but at romance? Not so much for either of them. That's part of the fun for me.

    1. Yes! That whole ending scene with Elizabeth bringing back Rosaleen was over-the-top silly; it was meant to be touching, inspiring and help Elizabeth since she blamed herself, however it didn’t quite come across as that. (Sadly, Abigail is missing from more than one episode… I think! My memories of these episodes are lacking… ugh.)

      The sparring between Jack and Elizabeth as regards education is always cute. These scenes mainly take place in the schoolhouse and were quite adorable. Especially the later scene when she’s miffed at Jack over learning about Rosemary and calls him a name he doesn’t know, then pertly tells him to “look it up.” ;)

      Romance does bring out a bit of the immaturity in this pair doesn’t it!? Gotta’ love it!

      Great thoughts yet again.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

(Enter your URL then click here to include a link to one of your blog posts.)

Optimized by Optimole