BEST MOVIES TO WATCH LIKE PRIME VIDEO’S ‘THE LOVE HYPOTHESIS’
This past week, the book adaptation genre gained another entrant into its club with the romance The Love Hypothesis. A title that dropped with Prime Video, it’s an ideal movie to ask what else there is to watch like it because, let’s be real, we all love a fun rom-com now and then.
LIST | 9 OF THE BEST SHOWS TO WATCH LIKE PRIME VIDEO’S ‘NEAGLEY’
BEST MOVIES TO WATCH LIKE PRIME VIDEO’S ‘THE LOVE HYPOTHESIS’ Share on XThe film is based on the novel (of the same name) by Ali Hazelwood and features the characters of Adam and Olive. One is a professor with a less than cheerful attitude, a personality that reaches throughout the college. The other is a Ph.D. candidate whose smarts sometimes lead her to misread social cues. If you watched the popular romance dramedy already (maybe for some more than once!), let’s dive in and see what else you can watch that seems similar to or like this new Prime Video title The Love Hypothesis.
BEST MOVIES to WATCH like THE LOVE HYPOTHESIS
40 DATES and 40 NIGHTS
This is a romance that is perhaps more of an indie title than big screen blockbuster or even streaming hit. It follows Bailee Madison’s Leah as a young woman who doesn’t have her “thing” and instead dates all the wrong people while not living up to her potential in her field of business. When she has another romantic entanglement go terribly wrong, she makes a bet with her grandmother to go on 40 dates believing she won’t find love.
The movie has some cute moments and has a recognizable cast if you love Netflix dramas. The scientific angle is missing from this one, but it has the complications of dating, plus it’s a 2026 romance so let’s just go with it.

Synopsis: Burned out on dating and ready to quit, Leah accepts her grandma’s outrageous challenge: 40 dates in 40 nights for a full year of rent. From awkward dinners to unexpected sparks, she discovers the biggest obstacle to love might be herself. – via Prime Video
Stream, at publication, 40 Dates and 40 Nights with Pluto TV; or find digitally on places like Prime Video
10 THINGS I HATE ABOUT YOU
A cult teen classic, this one has a fake dating situation that doesn’t really go well or even have smooth sailing given its heroine Bianca has so much sass and smarts. The film featured Julia Stiles and is largely considered hers and co-star Heath Ledger’s breakout film. It’s also a loose re-telling of Shakespeare as it tells a story of two people who hate each other and eventually find love in each other.
This also boasts some then-unknown stars who would later star in big titles.

Synopsis: New high school student Cameron (Gordon-Levitt) is smitten with Bianca (Oleynik), but in order to get around her father’s strict rules on dating, he must get bad boy Patrick (Ledger) to date Bianca’s ill-tempered sister, Kat (Stiles). – via Prime Video
Stream, at publication, 10 Things I Hate about You with Peacock; or find to digitally purchase on places like Prime Video
HOW to LOSE a GUY in 10 DAYS
This is a 2000s rom-com that has the whole bet situation and in many ways it plays into the fake dating scenario even if the would lovers Andie and Ben don’t really know they are in such a romantic complication. This is also that classic romantic comedy with the infamous yellow dress and a hero who some viewers despise. It’s been a long time since I have seen this film but I do remember liking the movie and even re-watching this one more than once.
This one also deserves a shout-out not just because it’s silly and rewatchable (in good ways) but because The Love Hypothesis star Lily Reinhart also paid homage by wearing a yellow dress during the press stops and events.

| TCD/Prod.DB | Alamy
Synopsis: A “How to…” columnist agrees to write a first-hand account about what it takes to drive a man out of your life… in exactly 10 days. – via Prime Video
Stream, at publication, How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days with Paramount+ or Prime Video
THE PROPOSAL
A fake dating concept and co-worker situation, this one has Sandra Bullock playing a high-powered exec in the publishing world who ends up convincing her (very) reluctant assistant to play her fiancé when it seems like she’ll be deported back to Canada. The pair take their lies to Alaska where Ryan Reynolds family lives. This one doesn’t seem to get high ratings, but it makes me laugh so much each time I rewatch it.
Synopsis: A high-powered editor proposes to her assistant to avoid deportation. – via Prime Video
Find to digitally purchase on places like Prime Video
MATERIALISTS
This one follows Dakota Johnson as a matchmaker and is a romance made in 2025 (or thereabouts) so definitely one with more modern ideals. The story is less of a com but does have romance and certainly uses the love triangle trope in a way that made people mad, but ending the opposite way would have diminished the lesson.
Synopsis: Dakota Johnson, Pedro Pascal, and Chris Evans take part in a love triangle in this romantic drama as a successful matchmaker, her perfect match… and her imperfect ex. – via Prime Video
Stream, at publication, with HBO Max; or find to digitally purchase on places like Prime Video
BONUS! GUARDING STARS – November 2026
This one is set to release this November and will have Jared Padalecki playing a hotshot action star who winds up needing protection. Enter Leighton Meester, a protection specialist who is assigned to protect this reclusive film star. To keep a secret from his family, the pair must pretend to date which makes this another (likely) fun fake dating rom-com. This is also based on a novel, The Bodyguard, from Katherine Center so it promises to be good.
Logline: When a no-nonsense bodyguard is assigned to protect a charming action star over the holidays sparks fly, secrets unravel, and Christmas gets a whole lot more complicated. – via Netflix
Stream exclusively with Netflix starting November 18
BONUS (aka the OUTLIER)! THE FANTASTIC FOUR
…and am I losing the plot (which is the cool (?) thing to say) with this addition? Perhaps. But this is a romantic story and it also deals with science things, too. A passion which the romantic couple both understand.
Is this a weird addition on a list movies to watch like The Love Hypothesis? Absolutely! However, it’s a movie that has lead characters who are scientific smart and it also has plenty of romance with its two leads who aren’t just building a life together, they also work together and help to make things better. Reed Richards and Sue Storm are two of the four in this story, and both have strengths that make their superhero team work.
Synopsis: Set against the backdrop of a ’60s-inspired, retro-futuristic world, Marvel’s First Family faces a daunting challenge. Forced to balance being heroes with their family bond, they must defend Earth from a space god and his enigmatic herald. – via Prime Video
Stream, at publication, Fantastic Four with Disney+; or find to digitally purchase on places like Prime Video
Find The Love Hypothesis now streaming exclusively with Prime Video
Photos: Alamy
Would you recommend any of these? How many of these movies like The Love Hypothesis would you watch or have you? What else would you add? Sound off below!
Note; this list was updated September 29, 2026
BROWSE even more
- ‘THE LOVE HYPOTHESIS’: PRIME VIDEO ROMANCE IS (EXPECTEDLY) STEAMY
- TWENTY YEARS OF THE BEAUTIFUL BBC ADAPTATION OF ‘JANE EYRE’
Thank you for visiting; return again anytime!
PINTEREST PIN – SAVE & SHARE


Do you have a favorite from this list?
I just watched 40 Dates and 40 Nights (that’s the most recent I’ve seen here) and I did think it was pretty cute. :)
These are all really good alternatives. I love that they are also all older movies… that I own. Ha!
I did think to myself during LH that the comedy of it all reminded me of The Proposal, which is one of my favorite movies. <3
The Proposal is one I watch anytime I want a laugh. It never ceases to make me giggle. :)