|

DEFENDING JEREMIAH FISHER AND A BIG ‘THE SUMMER I TURNED PRETTY’ PROBLEM


In recent years, there may be no buzzier unabashedly romance-y show that Prime Video’s The Summer I Turned Pretty. What I mean by this isn’t to say that the show is some blueprint for actual romantic storytelling, but in its global and generation gap appeal. As its third and final season draws to a close, I have thoughts (which the small reader content update group already saw) and as they whirl around, I decided to put them on paper, specifically to share some thoughts on defending Jeremiah Fisher.

The show is an adaptation of Jenny Han’s series which she also co-writes in its TV medium. It revolves around Isabel aka Belly (or Bels!) Conklin, and the boys of her summer days, Conrad and Jeremiah Fisher. The mothers of these families have been friends for years and each year, the Conklin’s spend time at the Fisher summer house. Many things happen but this is the gist of the streaming darling. Because Jeremiah Fisher has been receiving so much social media hate, I want to defend him and talk about, well, a problem with The Summer I Turned Pretty. Spoilers to follow.

TV SHOW REVIEW | ‘MY LIFE WITH THE WALTER BOYS,’ SEASON TWO IS ONE OF SECOND CHANCES

DEFENDING JEREMIAH FISHER AND A BIG ‘THE SUMMER I TURNED PRETTY’ PROBLEM. Talking about #PrimeVideo’s #TheSummerITurnedPretty. #TSITP Share on X

A glaring thing this show has against it is a love triangle (as an aside, if you do a love triangle, look at Dempsey’s Sweet Home Alabama character). We’ve seen it again and again but rarely with good results. For a good portion of season three, Jere is the one with Belly as the two plan a wedding, and to be kind, social media loathes him. Do I understand the irritation? Sure. But what I don’t understand is the unchecked adoration of the alternative, Conrad, being better.

DEFENDING JEREMIAH FISHER AND A BIG ‘THE SUMMER I TURNED PRETTY’ PROBLEM. Talking about my opinion that the younger Fisher shouldn't be the villain.
Photo: Amazon Studios / Prime Video | Alamy Stock Photo

Jeremiah messes up, then he gets caught and in time, as is her choice (right or wrong), Bels forgives him. Then he’s inconsiderate of her – as is she of him on one particular night, more than once. So, yes, I get it. Then we have Conrad. He gives and takes his love frequently and confesses again on her wedding weekend (no matter what, this is just no) while then expecting to be the victim in all of this. He also, from the way the actor plays him, seems to give zero, excuse the French, sh*ts. Meanwhile Jere (rightfully) decides not to marry Bels when he hears about Conrad’s confession because he’d like to have her whole heart, which culture would cheer if the sexes in this scenario were reversed. defending jeremiah fisher

Of the two brothers, I think Jeremiah is kinder about sharing his love.

Does he react in a wise, mature way? Heck no. Is he justified to feel pain and hurt? 110% yes. And we all know anyone else in this situation would get SM sympathy.

LIST | 20+ OF THE FILMS THAT SHOW US THE COLLEGIATE CLASSROOM

But then, here is the additional problem with The Summer I Turned Pretty.

No one is actually… likable. Yes, I said it. They don’t truly care about anyone else and everyone plays with each other’s hearts. Even the (mature) adults. Is it possible that the remaining episodes, which we can fairly assume will expand greatly on the time between the wedding and how Bels’ life evolves, will change my mind? Absolutely. It’s also true that I’ve forgiven some of these traits on other TV shows. Still, some characters and shows just affect me in all the wrong ways. This seems to be one of them.

If social media is the pinnacle of judging what is an “excellent teen romance” (constant lies, playing with hearts, disloyalty, cheating, cruelty, the same mistakes), well, I don’t want it. defending jeremiah fisher

Photo: AMAZON STUDIOS / Album

To its credit, up until now (because again, the book glosses heavily over post-wedding day) the show adapts the novels very well. So, I give it props for understanding first and foremost who its audience is and who the show needs to pull. But to have the story play so recklessly with the hearts of its characters (with each other) and then to convince us to believe so badly that there is really only one team, well, that I really cannot seem to forgive. And I am all about grace. These just feel purposeful mistakes.

At this point, I want this trio to fall madly, wholly and wonderfully in love with people who are not each other. (Update; I do appreciate how they are setting up the finale.) They need partners who will challenge them and show them that the best kind of love makes you feel safe (which by the way, Bels, you should want), at ease, and happy.

Instead, The Summer I Turned Pretty keeps going back to the same thing. Then asks us to root this on and further to like it while everyone is unkind. It’s exhausting and silly and unwise. When it comes to Jeremiah Fisher, I see his flaws. He needs to mature and grow up, but I don’t think pitting him as the villain and placing Conrad as the ideal is the way to go. Though it looks different, Conrad has lots of growing to do as well. In the meantime, I’ll just hold onto the opinions that Jere isn’t all bad and these characters need other people in their lives.

Global phenom this is, I suspect a spin off may happen which I can only hope uses the wisdom everyone is accusing Jeremiah of not having.

Photos: Alamy

What are your thoughts on this show? Do you think it has value? Would you see a spin off? Do you have any kind of leaning towards defending Jeremiah Fisher? Is Conrad your ideal? Share all of your thoughts below!

Thank you for visiting; please return again soon.

PINTEREST PIN – SAVE & SHARE


DEFENDING JEREMIAH FISHER AND A BIG ‘THE SUMMER I TURNED PRETTY’ PROBLEM. Talking about my opinion that the younger Fisher shouldn't be the villain.

About Rissi JC

amateur graphic designer. confirmed bookaholic. bubbl’r enthusiast. critical thinker. miswesterner. social media coordinator. writer.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

(Enter your URL then click here to include a link to one of your blog posts.)

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.